About this Episode
In this episode, Bree is joined by Dr Elise Stephenson, Deputy Director of the Global Institute for Women’s Leadership at the Australian National University, to talk about her new book, Space XX: Gender, Power and the New Space Race.
Elise uses the space sector as a case study of a young, fast-growing and well-resourced industry, and asks whether we are doomed to repeat the inequalities we see on Earth, or whether new sectors give us a real chance to build equality in from the start.
The conversation covers the concentration of power and wealth among a small group of tech leaders shaping both space and AI, why space matters far more to our everyday lives than most people realise, and what intergenerational thinking could offer the decisions being made right now.
Elise also shares her work mapping 10 forms of backlash, why pushback often peaks when progress is being made, and why the glass cliff shows that representation alone isn’t enough.
What You'll Learn
Why new and growing sectors offer a rare chance to design for equality rather than retrofit it
How the same group of tech leaders is shaping both the space and AI sectors, and why that matters
What seven generations thinking is, and why Elise argues for an intergenerational approach alongside an intersectional one
How to name and categorise backlash so you can use it as a leverage point in your organisation
Why resistance often shows up when you’re closest to making progress
What the glass cliff is, why the evidence still holds, and why equal numbers don’t mean equal conditions
Resources Mentioned
Keep Learning & Connect With Bree
If this episode sparked ideas or questions and you want to talk more about how I can support your team or organisation, book a free 20-minute call with me. I’d love to hear what you’re working on and explore how we can move the work forward, together.
📬 And don’t forget to subscribe to my newsletter for fresh insights, events and tools to support your inclusion journey.
-
Bree: So welcome back. It is DEI Will Not Die, and we've got a really exciting topic today that we certainly haven't touched on before, so I'm looking forward to today's conversation. But before we get into it, I do want to acknowledge that I am on Wadawurrung Country and pay my respects to Elders past and present, and a call out to any Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people who are listening to the podcast.
The sun is filtering in through my window today, which is nice. It's been a little bit chilly on Wadawurrung Country, and unfortunately the Barwon River, which has its traditional Wadawurrung name and is just about a ten minute walk from my house, is currently not doing so well because of the recent rains and the overflowing of sewers. That's impacting Country around here at the moment. Hopefully that will be rectified, or it will rectify itself, and we will do better from an infrastructure perspective to protect that body of water going forward.
My guest today has written a book that initially I didn't know I was going to read, but it's about space and it's about gender, and it is fascinating. I'm going to put a huge call out there. Obviously listen to this episode, but then absolutely get yourself a copy of this book, because it's super interesting, and share it around with people. I think it's going to have a lot of appeal to people on the periphery of these topics. But I won't steal any more of that thunder. Elise, welcome to the show. Would you be able to start by introducing yourself and letting the listeners know who you are and why you've written a book about space and gender?
Elise: Yeah, thanks so much, Bree. Nice to be here. So I'm Dr Elise Stephenson. I'm the Deputy Director of the Global Institute for Women's Leadership at the Australian National University. This is a research institute that's dedicated to gender equality in all of its various forms, across all different kinds of sectors and industries. It was founded by our first and only female prime minister to date, Julia Gillard, who remains our chair, so we're very lucky there. I'm joining from Ngunawal Country.
In the research that I do, I'm a bit of a policy, political science, international relations researcher, but I'm also a practitioner. I've run businesses, and I've worked with a lot of organisations across HR and across different aspects of organisational equality. Something that I've always come back to across many interactions has been this question: are we always doomed to repeat inequalities? Whether that's in a new business that starts, or a new government policy or legislation or department, or a new soccer group. Or is there actually an opportunity to get better, to redesign the wheel, to ingrain equality and justice and fairness and all of these concepts that seem to matter to us a lot as humans? Can we actually do this?
This is what's brought me to the research that I've done and this book that Bree has kindly been talking about, which is called Space XX: Gender, Power and the New Space Race. It's just been published by Monash University Publishing. In it I really unpack that question of whether we are doomed to repeat inequalities in space as we are on Earth. I use the space sector as one of many case studies of a sector that is growing really fast. It's got a ton of resources and energy, and quite a few tech billionaires, maybe even trillionaires, playing in this space.
We've got this opportunity where we can maybe rewrite the rules, where if we alter the trajectory even by 1%, have more women at the table, and address gender equality and other forms of diversity, maybe we can set ourselves on a new trajectory. So it's an exciting space to work in. It's certainly not the only space I work in, but I think it's a really good microcosm to look at some of the trends that we're seeing in the world, and that you cover on your podcast and in the work that you do, Bree, and to identify tangible leverage points where we can change things.
Bree: Yeah, I really like that. As I've been reading through the book, it is about the space sector, but it's so much about gender equality, diversity, equity and inclusion in organisations, decision making and workplaces holistically, which are obviously the conversations that we're having and need to be having. I also like how some of your research has been focused on AI, and how there are quite a few similarities between those two sectors. Could you talk a little bit about that overlap?
Elise: Yeah. I think AI is the topic on everyone's mind right now. I partnered with the Victorian Women's Trust to recently release a research snapshot mapping the gendered harms of AI, going beyond deepfakes and biased LLMs to map 20 different types of gendered harms that we're seeing. It really points out that the patterns of harm or inequality we're seeing are quite structured. They're not isolated, they're not one-off, and they require us to have this big vision.
The two sectors are related for a number of reasons. Firstly, we are talking about the same technologists who own the space sector and the AI development sector. They generally happen to be the same entities. You only have to look at Jeff Bezos and Blue Origin, Elon Musk and SpaceX, or Google and Anthropic, all of these big tech companies. There's a concept that's becoming more well recognised called the broligarchy. It's this discussion of how, particularly out of the US, we've got a new brand of leaders who are technologists. They're playing in politics and in public policy as well, they are incredibly wealthy, and they're almost exclusively men.
I was reading some analysis the other day. With folk like Elon Musk and Jeff Bezos, we know their wealth is surpassing nations, and one analysis had their wealth surpassing about 170 of the world's nations. That's incredible. So when you're talking about the concentration of power and wealth, this is what really interests me, because it's not just a human resources and human relations issue, although that is really important. We are also talking about who actually gets to make all manner of very consequential decisions that impact on the whole of humanity. Is it just this one group of people?
So how organisations and sectors are made up really matters, but it goes well beyond that. We've got great research from international relations that links gender inequality and domestic and family violence in the home to a country's propensity to engage in interstate warfare. These are not inconsequential or merely organisational issues. They actually matter to the safety and security of our nations, and therefore to our future as humanity. That's what I always like to reinforce. These are really interlinked issues and topics.
Bree: Absolutely. And honestly, that's what scared me a bit reading the book: that concentration of power you describe, who it sits with, and what the decision making processes are around what these people get to do with this incredible wealth and this access to space. I know there was a part in the book about Elon Musk's little, what has been described as his dick pic to space. Could you maybe talk us through that?
Elise: Yeah, absolutely. This is a bit of a funny one. You're right, there are parts of the book that are frightening, and then there are a lot of parts that are fun and funny, and this example is a bit emblematic of that. You might not have been aware, or maybe you were if you're a space person, but in 2018 SpaceX launched its largest rocket to date, the Falcon Heavy. The rocket had a payload that included a red Tesla Roadster that belonged to Musk. Commentators at the time said this signified masculinity and power and wealth and speed. Inside the Tesla Roadster there was a male mannequin, the Starman. He was in the front seat with his arm draped over the door.
One of our brilliant space archaeologists here in Australia, Dr Alice Gorman, has studied all of the crazy, wacky and interesting things that humans have launched into space. After Musk launched the Falcon Heavy with its Tesla Roadster and its Starman, she asked, have we just sent the equivalent of a dick pic into space? I think it's a really pertinent question to ask. In the book I make the comment that, in the communal, representative sense of the word "we", I don't think we launched a dick pic into space. But it certainly was launched, and it was launched by some of our male technologists.
Bree: Yeah, with way too much money, right? You've alluded to this a bit in your answers already, but with so much inequality on Earth and so much for us to tackle here, why should we be looking at inequalities in the space industry and space in general?
Elise: For me it goes back to this opportunity we have. We've got so many industries and sectors across the world and across Australia that have had inequality embedded in them for a really long time. What we know from the research is that how an institution or organisation was formed will forever impact its onward trajectory. So it really matters if a company was founded all by men, with a workforce that was majority men, and systems that suited that particular workforce and ownership model. Likewise, it really matters if you are founded with a gender equal team, or with diversity and representation. It's not just about how you go about doing the work and some of the values. It's also the norms, the policies, the rules, the intention that gets set up.
So for me, studying sectors like the space sector is a pretty unique opportunity. I spend all of my time in this world, dedicated to making sure that humans of all backgrounds have the best opportunities we can provide them, with fairness, equality and respect in the world and in their workplaces. Sectors like space are a unique opportunity for us to do things differently because they are still pretty young and pretty malleable, and they've got lots of new organisations and institutions, which means we might have a better chance of getting it right. I think we can all appreciate how hard it is to keep pushing a big boulder up a hill, always pushing against time. Newer sectors and industries offer us something different.
That's at a large level. At a more targeted level, space is also really interesting because when I speak to most people, they might be aware of Katherine Bennell-Pegg, Australia's first astronaut under the Australian flag and also our first female astronaut. They might think rockets. But do they know much about space, where it is and what it does? Maybe not. It might surprise you. You might have used GPS to navigate to your kid's school this morning, or to order Uber Eats last night. That's space tech. Maybe you lay your head on a memory foam pillow. That's space tech. Maybe you use a cochlear hearing device. That's space tech. Space tech is everywhere.
When we're considering really big global challenges, like approaching an Australian summer bushfire season, we're relying on satellite data to monitor for bushfires and to plan emergency evacuations. Space is everywhere, and it really matters to all of us. One of the points I make in the book is that maybe it was a young grad who was overlooked who first took some sort of space health innovation and used it to save your mum's life.
So the workers who are part of our sector, and the way gender equality and other forms of diversity show up in it, matter. It's not just about making sure that not only our sons but also our daughters get these sorts of opportunities. It's also about whether we're narrowing the pool of imagination when it comes to how critical innovations could be used in the world, and fundamentally it's about questions of equality and justice.
This is a critical sector that is now talking about, in Elon's words, colonising Mars, or mining the Moon. These are hugely consequential. We've had generations of connection as humans with our sky. What happens if next time you look up, the Moon looks a little bit different because we've started mining it? We know the destruction and devastation these sorts of things have brought on Earth. I'm not saying we would do anything differently if we had more diverse representation in the room, but we should have that opportunity, so that as humanity we take steps forward that we've all had a bit of a say in. So there's so much more we can be doing in this sector, for space, but also as emblematic of other sectors that we can really change.
Bree: Yeah. I really liked that thinking in the book, and what you've shared around Indigenous and First Nations perspectives on space, but also on decision making. In one chapter you talk about seven generations thinking, which goes to what you were just speaking about. Can you tell us a little bit about what that is, and how our approach to space in the future could be different if we embodied a bit more of this kind of thinking?
Elise: Seven generations thinking is common amongst many Indigenous peoples and communities across the world. In other parts of the world it's been called cathedral thinking: the idea that you build the foundations of the cathedral before you know how to complete the arch. You're setting up future generations to benefit from or enjoy a particular piece of work. What it comes down to, for a sector like space or artificial intelligence or any of these other sectors, is that we aren't foreclosing future generations' opportunities or options through decisions we make today. Climate change is an easy one for people to grasp. We don't want to foreclose future generations' options because of our decisions around climate today. But this is typically what we do.
In my field of work, and perhaps in your listeners' fields of work, we might be really used to thinking about intersectionality: the idea that in workplaces or communities, gender and race and socioeconomic status and disability and sexuality can combine to impact on an individual's opportunities, challenges and life course. What I also advocate for, alongside that, is an intergenerational approach. This is an approach that takes into account not only all current living generations, but also future generations, and the future we're setting them up for. Particularly around a lot of this work, I really want future generations to look back and say, they tried. They didn't just leave us to these consequences. They actually tried to embed some of these things from the start.
There have been some great philosophers and researchers who have looked into this, including in the area of artificial intelligence, and they find that if we don't confront the way we're setting up artificial intelligence or the space sector, or even our actions on climate change, right now, we're locking in today's norms and values, and future generations will forever have to deal with the consequences. So that's why I'm so keen that we get this as close to right as we can, now.
This is a real intergenerational issue, given that the World Economic Forum still forecasts we're over a hundred years from attaining any type of gender parity in the world, and that's only on the proviso that we continue at the current rate of progress. And I would note that in the space sector, just in the last two years, more entities have regressed on women's representation than have progressed, particularly space agencies. So we've got stuff to do here.
Bree: Yeah, and we're seeing that across sectors as well. Thinking about people doing DEI work and gender equality work within organisations, I'm having a lot of people come to me saying they've hit their head against a brick wall for long enough. They realise their organisation is never going to put the money in, never going to put the resourcing in, never really going to create the systemic change that's needed for equality, and they're feeling like they're at their end. You're working in a sector that, as you've described, is going backwards, and didn't start from a great base in terms of the representation of people who aren't white, straight, able-bodied men. Yet you're still pushing through and still working very fervently on these topics. What keeps you at it? What keeps you believing this is valuable and that we can make change?
Elise: Look, I understand where your listeners are coming from. You matter. You absolutely have to keep going in this space. From a research point of view, one of the things I think will be an enduring resource beyond space as a case study is a chapter that's all on backlash. I've gone through and defined 10 different ways backlash shows up in the work that we do.
Some of it is things like inaction. We've all experienced this. Maybe it's an organisation that just decides, no, we're not going to do that, or we're not going to fund that, or your position no longer exists. There are things like disavowal, where your organisation does say, yes, of course diversity, equity and inclusion matter, but it's actually the responsibility of government to legislate, or blah, blah, blah. So they don't take responsibility.
I go right through 10 different ways we see backlash or pushback show up. I've talked about this at a number of different forums, from UN Women's annual summit to other organisations, and I always get a lot of good feedback. People say, I always had this feeling that it wasn't right, and I knew I was hitting a wall, but I didn't know what language I could use around it. Having the language and a way to categorise it, to say, no, this is explicitly what's going on here, really helps. Anecdotally, I've heard of people being able to go back to their leadership or their organisation and say, I appreciate what you said, but this is actually showing up as this. We do need to act. Here's our mandate, and here are our responsibilities to our workers and to society. So they've been able to use it as a leverage point.
The second thing is I've also got a whole section on navigating backlash. What we know from the research is that in many circumstances, the point at which you'll receive the most pushback or backlash is actually when progress is being made. When you come closer to equality, that's often when we'll see stagnation or regression, but that's because you're close. We also know from many studies that those who believe equality has already been achieved are most at risk of perpetrating inequality. So there are all these stats and facts and figures throughout the book, which I think adds some ammunition.
For your listeners, I think you should all be really proud of the work you continue to do, even when times are tough. The reality remains that humans are infinitely diverse, and infinitely capable of an infinite number of things. I recognise there's been a lot of politicisation and a lot of backlash, but I think this is an enormous opportunity and an enormous privilege. As a society, we should be very grateful for the people who work in this field, because at the end of the day it's about ensuring our future generations have it better than we did, and that we can keep improving that, whether for our workers, our families or society more generally.
Bree: Well, that could be a perfect accompaniment to the title of this podcast, because that is exactly why it's called DEI Will Not Die. The work doesn't go. It doesn't disappear. It doesn't matter what policy changes are made, the need is still there. And as you say, when we start doing good stuff and making progress, that's when we see the resistance, and it's a cycle. I love that advice around getting tactical: let's work out what the backlash is, why it's there, and what we know works against it. There's so much great research out there, and that's another great reason for grabbing this book.
A question off the cuff to round us up. The book talks about the glass cliff, and those who are listening may have seen some research out recently saying it's all rubbish and not true. Would you be able to explain the glass cliff, why it's relevant, and why we need to be conscious of it when we're doing this work?
Elise: Yeah, absolutely. The glass cliff was a concept coined by my boss, the director of the Global Institute for Women's Leadership at ANU, Professor Michelle Ryan, and her co-investigator, Alex Haslam. Over 20 years ago they identified a trend where women would be put in leadership positions right at the moment where the chance of failing was highest, or where there was great risk or precarity. So a company was tanking, and all of a sudden they'd put a woman in. In the media there were all these claims that so-and-so organisation appointed a woman and now the company is failing. But when you looked at the causal mechanism or the timing, the company was already failing, and then they put in a woman to rescue the situation. Whether or not she did, she was put in a glass cliff scenario, pushed off the edge, we could say.
Since then, Michelle and others have done a huge number of studies that have found this trend holds true across an enormous range of backgrounds, industries and sectors. It's natural that there's going to be pushback around that, but the evidence is pretty conclusive that this trend tends to hold. It could be women, or it could be other minoritised people, put in when risk is high, when the role has just been demoted, or when funding is at its lowest point. I've studied it in diplomacy and found it, and studied it in the space sector and found it.
So it's something we really have to be aware of, because it pushes us to see that representation isn't enough. We should always be aiming for representation, because it is key. But even if you've got equal numbers of men and women and other genders in the room, that doesn't mean the circumstances of their employment or position are equal, or that the precarity and risks are equal. There's lots of great research on that. If you're interested, you can follow along with the Global Institute for Women's Leadership. We run a number of events and put out media and research on this topic. Always happy to chat more about it.
Bree: Excellent. Thank you for grabbing that one. There's been a lot of misinformation out there and it's having an impact. And for those listening, remember that the research talks about the most senior roles, but we also see this commonly happen with teams that aren't performing well, or that have turned into a really toxic environment. Organisations will put a woman, or somebody from a minority gender or a marginalised background, in because they'll be softer and able to do the people stuff, again potentially setting people up for failure. So be conscious of that in your own organisations.
Awesome. Thank you for coming on and sharing this with us, and for the book. I'm looking forward to reading the rest of it. As I said, I'm over halfway through now and I'm obsessed, so please get yourself a copy, people. We'll put links to all of this in the show notes, and I'll get Elise to send through any other links that might be relevant for you to read and watch. Thank you so much for coming on, and I'll be seeing you at the book launch.
Elise: Yeah, and for anyone who's around Sydney or Melbourne, we'll have more dates up too. I'm very easy to find online on LinkedIn, or you can look at the Global Institute for Women's Leadership website. I'm just so happy to chat to anyone and work with anyone out there around these issues. It's hard at times, but there are allies like myself out there doing the work to connect the evidence, what we know works, with what's done in the real world. So we're here to support you.
Bree: Awesome. Thanks everyone for listening, and we'll catch you on the next episode.
Elise: Thank you.